Thanks for the support Rich. And just for the record, I was trying to be very cordial over the phone. I got the replacement tire and return tag today. Monday Im going back to the shop and swap it over and then spend more money balancing them for the 4th time. Fingers crossed its not worse! As far as the other tire, I'll swap it with the new spare I have in the Aquamist car. Hopefully this will take care of it.